The Heart Of What It Means To Lead

Fleming Rutledge, in The Battle for Middle-earth: Tolkien’s Divine Design in The Lord of the Rings said that, “…the important matter here is that we are being shown that the true leader is the one who takes the burden of the battle upon himself, no matter what sort of battle it is” (p. 238). This message resonates with Christian teachings and leadership attributes in general because it reflects the principle of servant leadership, which is a core tenet of Jesus’s ministry. In Christianity, as in all leadership, true leadership is exemplified by humility, sacrifice, and the willingness to bear burdens for others.

Jesus himself demonstrated this by taking on the sins of humanity through his suffering and crucifixion, emphasizing the idea that a true leader serves and sacrifices for the well-being of others rather than seeking power or recognition. This concept encourages individuals to approach leadership with compassion and a commitment to supporting those they lead, which aligns closely with many biblical passages about love, service, and selflessness.
By focusing on the leader who takes on burdens, Rutledge’s message, pointing out lessons from J.R.R. Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings, calls for a deeper understanding of responsibility and empathy in leadership roles, encouraging us to look beyond traditional notions of authority to the heart of what it means to lead.
Rutledge also pointed to a comment made by Gandalf to Théoden in The Lord of the Rings. Gandalf’s statement, “But your people must not be both unarmed and shepherdless.… Who shall guide and govern them in your place?” (p. 238), emphasized the importance of leadership and guidance, particularly in times of uncertainty or crisis. It highlights that effective leaders are not just figureheads; they carry the responsibility of providing direction, protection, and support to their people. The phrase “unarmed and shepherdless” suggests that without proper leadership and care, followers may become vulnerable, lost, or unable to navigate challenges.
This aligns with the biblical themes I mentioned earlier of love, service, and selflessness, as true leaders embody these principles by prioritizing the well-being of others and taking on burdens for the sake of those they lead. Just as Gandalf calls for a leader who is willing to guide and protect, many biblical passages encourage leaders to serve with humility and compassion, reflecting a deep sense of responsibility towards their community. In essence, both Gandalf’s perspective and the teachings found in scripture underscore that effective leadership is rooted in empathy, active service, and a commitment to the collective good.
I loved what Rutledge said at the end of this section in her book. She said, “Thus Gandalf is gently and tactfully reminding Théoden of his less glamorous but equally important responsibility of shepherding” (p. 238). As I always say, human-centered leadership is not glamorous. This idea of shepherding is an important one. It was also an important role for Tolkien. A shepherd (leader) rears, provides care, and provides guidance.
leave a comment