Ends and Means

In the great book The Battle for Middle-earth: Tolkien’s Divine Design in The Lord of the Rings, Fleming Rutledge pointed out the examples of “ends and means” arguments in J. R. R. Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings. Speaking about the ends justifying the means, Rutledge said, “The truth of life is that we have very little control over “ends” because of the law of unintended consequences. The only thing that lies within our power is the means to the hoped-for end” (p. 139). This reminds us that while we may have clear goals or desired outcomes (“ends”), we often cannot fully control the results due to unpredictable factors and unforeseen consequences (“the law of unintended consequences”).
Just like in The Lord of the Rings, our actions, though driven by good intentions, can set off chain reactions with unpredictable and often profound consequences. The only aspect genuinely within our control is the way we approach and pursue those goals. Our actions, efforts, and means matter. This all emphasizes the importance of focusing on how we work towards our aims, trusting that ethical and mindful means are crucial because we can’t always guarantee specific outcomes.
leave a comment