Follow The Argument Wherever It Leads

In God In The Dock, C. S. Lewis reminded us that “Socrates had exhorted men to ‘follow the argument wherever it led them’” (p. 126). Actually, Socrates said, “We must follow the argument wherever, like a wind, it may lead us” (Republic 394d). Socrates argued (pun intended) that one should not be afraid of questioning or challenging ideas and beliefs, even if they seem uncomfortable or go against commonly accepted views. By urging us to follow the argument, Socrates was urging us to explore and engage in intellectual discussions without preconceived biases or limitations. There is power in critical thinking and the pursuit of truth through logical reasoning.

Lewis’ statement is so true: “Each group hears not the best, but the worst, that the other group can say” (p. 127). There is a tendency for groups or individuals to only hear and focus on the negative aspects or criticisms coming from others. He wanted us to recognize this bias and strive to approach discussions and disagreements with an open mind, actively seeking out the best arguments and perspectives from all sides. By doing so, we can foster a more constructive and empathetic dialogue, leading to a better understanding of different viewpoints and ultimately a more inclusive and tolerant society.

Byron's Babbles